Deer Hunting Forums banner
1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
295 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
A matter of semantics.

When did we become farmers? When did we start growing deer? When did we start working at grocery stores instead of hunting? At what point did we start wrestling and setting fire to deer and other big game?

As an outdoor writer with over a half-century of experience writing for outdoor publications, I have often been asked to change the wording n some of my writing. On one point, I staunchly refuse.

I am not a farmer. I do not harvest deer. I am a hunter. I kill deer and I make no excuse for it. That is what I do. I am not a bag boy at a grocery store. I do not bag deer. I kill them. I am a hunter. I have never smoked a deer or given one a dirt bath. I have killed many.

Why must hunters succumb to such a ridiculous example of politically correctness? Hunting is a right, a privilege and a matter of heredity. Hunters kill. I kill. I do not harvest or bag or any of the cute phrases coined by television “stars”. I was on television for five years. Not once did I give anything a dirt bath or smoke a deer or elk. I killed them. When I did, they were not down. They were dead. Not one time did I pump my fist and say, "He's down! He's down." If I said anything at all, I said, "He's dead."

Why must we use any other word for what we do? We hunt. We kill. We have no catch and release.:rolleyes::wallbash:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,271 Posts
I get what you're saying... but I don't have a problem with the word harvest. Just because you harvest something doesn't mean you grew it. You are harvesting the deer on your property for a better good- to feed your family and/or other people.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
824 Posts
"Hunting is a right, a privilege and a matter of heredity."
Agree with you 110% on this!!!

"I do not harvest or bag or any of the cute phrases coined by television “stars”."
Guess I'm missing out (or not) with this one. Don't watch other folks out hunting, would rather be doing so myself.

"We have no catch and release."
Kind of hard to get the bullet or arrow back once it's been fired or released. You have no argument from me with you there either.

Political correctness (to me) has had its place in society - notice the past tense - but now I think it's time for people to put their 'political correctness' aside and start realizing that unless they stand up for what they believe in, then everything that's been fought for over the past 235 or so years will be lost. What's that old line from the C&W song?? "You've gotta fight for something -- or you'll fall for anything!"

Okay, I'll get off my soapbox now . . . . .

RR
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
5,711 Posts
I get what you're saying... but I don't have a problem with the word harvest. Just because you harvest something doesn't mean you grew it. You are harvesting the deer on your property for a better good- to feed your family and/or other people.
I agree......
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,220 Posts
Political correctness is a pet pieve of mine, I hate it when people just can't say what they mean and be done with it. Now that we have a bonified profesional outdoor writer in our midst do we have to use correct grammer and spelling?
:rolleyes:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
295 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Political correctness is a pet pieve of mine, I hate it when people just can't say what they mean and be done with it. Now that we have a bonified profesional outdoor writer in our midst do we have to use correct grammer and spelling?
:rolleyes:
Not if youens are from E. TN. It isn't expected. :lol:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
3,347 Posts
I use those phrases myself & not to be PC
to me it is just hunting talk or in the moment of excitement "I smoked him"
"or Bagged me a good un" Have No issues with it myself
& will say what I want. I am more concerned about keeping my privilege to hunt then what people call "killing a deer"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,271 Posts
I use those phrases myself & not to be PC
to me it is just hunting talk or in the moment of excitement "I smoked him"
"or Bagged me a good un" Have No issues with it myself
& will say what I want. I am more concerned about keeping my privilege to hunt then what people call "killing a deer"

I agree with GFD... I think many of those terms are used just because the hunter is PUMPED up because he/she just made a good shot. Now, granted there are some hunters on TV that are so goody-goody that I can't stand watching them (ahh hemm, David Morris).

Now, typically I always say harvest, but I see nothing wrong with the other sayings... but I get where you're coming from. To each his own.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
95 Posts
Don't think it's a case of being pc. Think it's just trying to use different words to kill. If you wrote kill kill kill kill kill all the time it would get boring. Maybe.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,461 Posts
Folks, I'll call it like I see it, free speech entitles me to say what I want and how I want. :yes: Not looking to start any writers quarrel :ranting: but I don't see an issue here that warrants much debate! :coffee: We all express ourselves as individuals it's what separates us from each other. I harvest, take, remove, eliminate, reduce, control, and yes, kill deer. I really don't care what phrase is used it all means the same to me. Obviously, I'm not a professional writer thus I'm not concerned with PC issues! :thumbdown:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
799 Posts
Folks, I'll call it like I see it, free speech entitles me to say what I want and how I want. :yes: Not looking to start any writers quarrel :ranting: but I don't see an issue here that warrants much debate! :coffee: We all express ourselves as individuals it's what separates us from each other. I harvest, take, remove, eliminate, reduce, control, and yes, kill deer. I really don't care what phrase is used it all means the same to me. Obviously, I'm not a professional writer thus I'm not concerned with PC issues! :thumbdown:

not a whole lot going on any other time and its as good a debate as any other. I say keep em coming. we need to encourage more input into the forum. this is what makes things interesting.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,115 Posts
I think all these kind terms started when they realized the money that can be made with these shows.You see the pretty girls hunting and using the proper words.Hunting is now commercialized and big business.I make no apologies for my camp.WE DRINK BEER & WHISKEY,SWEAR,KILL& EAT DEER AND I WOULDNT CHANGE A THING.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
824 Posts
Me Neither!

I think all these kind terms started when they realized the money that can be made with these shows.You see the pretty girls hunting and using the proper words.Hunting is now commercialized and big business.I make no apologies for my camp.WE DRINK BEER & WHISKEY,SWEAR,KILL& EAT DEER AND I WOULDNT CHANGE A THING.
And I wouldn't change a thing either!!!

RR
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top