Deer Hunting Forums banner
1 - 20 of 51 Posts
G

·
i'm going with a privilege.

why because you are licensed to hunt. just as driving is a privilege and it can be taken away from you for various good reasons, so too with hunting. both should be treated with respect and with great responsibility.

good question, hm.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
799 Posts
Its a God given right.
in the most basic needs of life, you can survive without driving, so hence driving is a privledge.
hunting and fishing on the other hand such as gathering is the most basic of God given rights to survive. we only allow the state and federal governments to provide for licensing to maintain some form of game management and greed management.
 
G

·
so guys if you break the law and lost your licenses, you think its your right to hunt anyway? if you're a felon and go gun hunting its your right? cause thats what you are saying.

rights can not be taken away, privileges can. the entity taking that away isn't the gov'. its those that support the laws written and passed by those that were elected by the people/other hunters. well its suppose to be anyway. so its the law abiding hunter that is taking that privilege from you, and by you i mean those that lost thier privileges not you as in airbourne and wisconsindeer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
799 Posts
We must be careful what we call a right or a privledge and what we allow the federal, state and local governments to call a right or a privledge. after all a right can be renamed a privledge and thereby taxed, licensed, controled to no means and even revolked. hunting is a right that man has had since the garden of eden when God gave to him and Eve the skin of an animal to cloth themselve with. We allow our state and federal governments the privledge to require a license fee to be paid in order to legaly hunt in a given state. from those license fees we assumne that the game numbers will be managed and the welfare of the states game animals will be monitored and controlled. I do not advocate hunting or fishing without a license, but I refuse to consider it a privledge and I reserve the right to absolve the licesing requirements in the event of something catastrophic such as a high level enviromental disaster of another great depression.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Right to hunt.

In The State of Vermont, hunting is a right. It is so declared in the State Constitution. However it also says that the State can regulate and require a license to hunt. I forget the exact wording. Also remember when a person commits a felony he or she loses certain rights! Owning or possessing a firearm is one of them. In Vermont however a felon can still utilize his right to hunt, just has to use a muzzleloader instead of a rifle or shotgun. A felon may also use a bow and arrow in Vermont.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
5,710 Posts
MANY states voted hunting and fishing into their law books making it a "Right" not a privilege, a few states are still failing to get those laws passed but in time I believe It's going to be a "Right" for everyone.

If anyone wants to read the Bills that were established for their states here's the link that shows who passed and failed
"Right to hunt and Fish"

And joem46 is right, Vermonters are the only ones that have had the Right to hunt since 1777.

The Vermont Constitution states the following

Vermont
“The inhabitants of this State shall have the liberty in seasonable times, to hunt and fowl on the lands they hold, and on other lands not inclosed, and in like manner to fish in all boatable and other waters (not private property) under proper regulations, to be made and provided by the General Assembly.” (Vermont Constitution, Chapter 2, part 67, 1777)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,459 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
I think all have given good points but here is what I think. Because we live in a civilized sociaty, we have formed laws for which grant/take a-way rights, based upon a representative style of government, can be involked or revolked at any time. Your rights are only intack as long as the people stand up for their rights. Hunting cannot be a privelge as privelge is a term used for granting something special to someone or a special group. In this case, hunting is open to all (with certain requirements) and therefor becomes a right under law, which then means someone or something has allowed the right to take place. What I was looking for was the acknowledgement that what we believe are our rights are only true as long as the majority of the people say it is. I didn't go into the religious rights as I believe we have certain individual rights that man cannot take away. Most rights as we think of them are only a temporary right based upon the next vote of the people. To me, hunting is a right for now!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
168 Posts
I agree hunting man except that our "rights" given to us by our founding fathers in the Bill of Rights were consisdered God given rights. We are losing these rights because people have refused to acknowledge a god period let alone that he has given us rights as expressed in our constitution
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
799 Posts
What I was looking for was the acknowledgement that what we believe are our rights are only true as long as the majority of the people say it is.
Actually, anything you deem to be your rights, are your rights regardless of what the majority thinks or believes. It all depends on how much you are willing to defend what you believe.


Some would argue that the 2nd amendment is not a right of the people, which is really irrelevant as long as someone is willing to stand up and claim it as a right and defend it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
799 Posts
Rights are granted by the constitution and bill of rights. If it ain’t there it is a privilege.
I disagree!!

These are just defined rights, not all of them. These are only rights afforded by the government, which in most all cases proves inadequate.
 
G

·
ok i think some may be looking at it a little backwards. these "rights", and hunting isn't one of them but, weren't granted, afforded, or given to us, by the words on the paper. they words on the paper stop them from being taken away by gov't.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
55 Posts
I have purposely not read the other replies to this post so my reply will not be influenced by what others have said. I believe that rights are God given and can't be taken away. priviledges are on the other hand are afforded us by governments and can be taken from us. All I have to say is I believe hunting is a god given right for the siimple reason that in the Book of Acts, chapter 11, verse 4 God tells Peter "rise, kill, eat"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,459 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Sir Smackabuck, while I like to agree with your thoughts, the problem is if the federal gonernment outlawed all hunting and you continued to hunt and got caught and throwned in jail what would be your options? If the Constitution was ammended to outlaw hunting what would you do? I'm only asking questions as I don't have the answers either. I simply wanted people to think about hunting and why we need to protect it through good representatives and government. This I do know if my family was starving no law would prevent me from feeding them!:wink:
 
1 - 20 of 51 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top