Deer Hunting Forums banner

How big is this buck???

5735 Views 14 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  joel the signman
What do you fellas think about this. I cant size or age deer so i leave it to the pros, whats your best guess. I know its a poor picture but hes a 4x4 with heavy mass all the way through

See less See more
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
kinds dark to really see.looks big though
He's what I would call WOW. That's a BIG OLD deer. Its a summer pic so he's not got his rutting weight on but he is big anyway. Big ole sway back. Fat ole belly that drags on the ground almost. I'm guessing that deer is at least 5 and I would say he was 6 years old. The number of inches ??? no way to tell being in velvet but it would be enough for me.
I hope you don't mind....tried to brighten the image......
I no expert by anymeans but I am gonna say about 6.5yrs old......I'd also say he will be around the 140 - 145 mark when he gets done growin
See less See more
Pist.... ETD the half won't come in till this fall but i think you are right and good job with the pic.

oh yeah where is this deer???? exactly?
no question that's an old buck, maybe the oldest one posted so far.
I know nothing about aging a deer but I do know that he is one GREAT animal.
from what i have read on this site the only way to tell is by the teeth. where is it at? let me shoot him, and i will let you know.
A tooth is a way to get a positive age. By looking at different things on the live deer you can get a good idea how old it is. Its like looking and a 11year old, a 22 year old, a 30 year old, and a 50 year old human male. there are books out there to help you tell the difference and I'm sure there are magazine articles as well. The 1.5 buck looks like a doe with horns. little short face and slight all over. The 2.5 looks like a big doe and is a little front end heavy, with a longer face. the 3.5 looks like an athlete or a race horse, straight back thinner at the belly than the chest. the 4.5 gets the pot belly and the legs look short, the 5.5 has that sway back and big sagging belly and their face comes right out of their necks. the over the hill deer 7.5 and older just look gaunt. assuming all the deer are hard horned and before the rut.

How did I do guys and gals? did I get it about right?
I think you summed it up really well Ronn... Good Posting...

I also hope "Edgecrusher" doesn't mind I did a little edit too..

I think this is a typical 8 pointer in velvet in this pic, I'm not so sure it's going to score as well as EastTexasDroptine thinks it might, once he loses the velvet and the antlers harden and shrink, I think it's going to score in around 130. I also think it's currently only about 5 years old. (5.5 this season) that's just my opinion, the body is still a good solid muscular frame and he's just starting to develop the sagging belly Ronn mentioned. another thing I notice is the peaking shoulders sloping down to the neck, I'm sure he's seen a couple good heavy ruts with that neck swelling and shrinking.
All in All it's a great buck I wish you loads of luck pursuing him... <-click to see the deer
I was just watching QDMA and they said virtually everything you looking at a 1.5 year old deer is like a teenager......Bucks also have the biggest "antler jump" in terms of size from ages 3.5 yrs to 4.5 yrs.

Found these websites with pics to help age on the hoof.....
Field Guide from Wildlife Enterprises
Quality Deer Management Association
Really like this last website/powerpoint....
ronn thats a good posting. Also, with really good food supply like here in Ohio bucks can carry a real good rack 6-8 years then start the big fall off, providing their not on a wall. I just watched a show that spent a good deal of time showing bucks and how they age in physical appearance. After the 4.5 age they really fill out and have that box car look, solid head to tail.
Thanks. A good reason for nutrition plots. I read or saw somewhere that those 180"+ deer that we see taken in IL. on TV are predominantly 3.5 years old. just imagine what a couple more years on them could do.
great info ronn and Droptine
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.