I am not fond of any hunting clubs that are for profit. I was merely talking about my own personal land that we try to manage. By paying attention to our herd we have taken steps to make herd stronger.
By allowing you bigger, stronger bucks to breed more does, you will most likely have bigger bucks in a few years. However, you have to realize that bigger, stronger bucks don't always make bucks when they breed....they often produce does. And a doe with big, strong genetics is more likely to pass those on to its fawns. This is only increasingly better for the strength and health of your herd.
I personally believe that Tennesse has a lot of potential for making big bucks. I just don't believe there are many people who try and grow them here. I have seen many bucks that were or were at least close to B & C and more than several that would classify as P & Y come from my property or at least the area. All it takes is the right food, the right amount, and hunters who don't shoot at everything they see. I understand hunting to fill a freezer, but if you do that.....just shoot a few does.
I am not a trophy hunter but anyone who frequents decent woods knows that small 1-2 yr old bucks are a dime a dozen. The true thrill ( at least for me) is growing and trying to out smart the wise 3-4 yr old monster. I don't hunt for the size of the rack but often, when you are trying to hunt the smartest and most skilled deer, it often turns out you are hunting a monster.