Deer Hunting Forums banner

Can ( insert name ) drop a deer?

1964 Views 4 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  daddus1
I am relatively new to the muzzleloading scene, I have bowhunted for several years now and decided to take the plunge. As i do when I get into any new hobby or purchase I end up doing ALOT of reading. I have noticed alot of ML forums have someone that always pops up and ask can ( insert gun mfg/model ) drop a deer.

Today I was watching some borrowed hunting videos ( sprained ankle/ nothing better to do ) and I came across a hunt that answers that question with ease. DVD is called Moose Mania 1 w/ Ralph & Vicki Cianciarulo. It advertises the muzzleloader shot on the back cover, the short of it is a 199 3/8" scored Canadian Moose shot at 146 yards and recovered in 30 yards. Shot was made with a traditions pursuit topped with a Nikon scope ( rifle variant wasnt specified but from looking at it I think it was an xlt ). The load out was 100gr of pyroxdex powder and a 250gr saboted Traditions APB 100 projectile.

If 100gr of pyrodex and 250gr saboted bullet can drop a 1500+lb moose at 146yds I am quite certain it can handle a 200+lb whitetail. It all comes down to shot placement and how comfortable you are with your weapon. Another realization I have came upon is I will be limited to what powders, pellets and projectiles I can get in decent quantities and prices locally.

All that to say if you have a decent muzzleloader, no matter what name engraved in the barrel, a sensible powder load and a decent projectile you can drop just about anything that walks in the woods.
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
I have a .54 cal, and have to drive 20 minutes to find sabots and conicals , but I live in a small town, but I can get different powders with little or no problem. Most stores carry a lot of .50 cal stuff, so if you get a .50 you should be fine. :bye:
:goodposting: txvstar, Greetings from Vermont & Welcome to the Club.
hello and welcome to the site. You'll find lots of muzzleloader shooters/hunters here.
The load you mentioned will pretty much do the job you desire.
The real trick is safety and good shot placement.
Welcome there are a good bunch of guys on this site all willing to help.
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.