I'm happy you killed a nice deer, but you don't know that the scent you used is the absolute reason you killed him. I've used more scents over the years than I can count, and yes I've watched deer track me almost right to my stands when I used some of them and also tracked me the same way when I didn't use any. Honestly, for me, a little Scent Killer and ESPECIALLY watching where I walk works better than expecting scent to be a fix all. And I fully understand what you're saying, if you feel confident using this particular scent, by all means keep using it. Just my observations over A LOT of years and my 2 cents.